My Beautiful Passport contains affiliate links. We may receive a small commission (at no extra cost to you) on qualifying purchases so we can continue to create helpful content. Thank you, and we appreciate it. See our disclosure policy for more information.

| | |

Aruba vs Barbados: Which is Better for Vacation?

ByMelissa

Debating whether Aruba vs Barbados is a better destination for your next Caribbean vacation can be a tough choice if you haven’t been to either island before. 

While these two islands share some similarities, after visiting both Barbados and Aruba, they are both unique and can appeal to different types of adventurers. 

Both islands offer stunning beaches and a rich history, but Aruba has a more diverse food scene while Barbados has the best beaches. 

Let’s find out if Aruba or Barbados is a better fit for you!

This post may contain affiliate links. We may receive a small commission (at no extra cost to you) on qualifying purchases so we can continue to create helpful content. Thank you, and we appreciate it. See our disclosure policy for more information.

Aruba vs Barbados Overview

Before we dive into an in-depth comparison, here’s a quick overview of what you can expect from each island:

Infographic comparing the islands Aruba vs Barbados, to help someone decide which island to visit for their vacation. The background is light blue with a graphic of sand and 2 palm trees on the bottom. The pros and cons comparing each island are in a boxed section in a white background, with seashell icons as bullet points. Text on graphic says: Which Island is better? Quick comparison Aruba vs Barbados Aruba: - Easier to get around without a car - More options for accommodations - Better hiking trails - More food options Barbados: - Cheaper seafood options - Less commercialized, more authentic - More affordable luxury hotels - Easier to swim with turtles

Cost of Stay 

While both islands are expensive due to their popularity and limited resources. I found it easier to find affordable luxury in Barbados than in Aruba.

Woman in a sundress leaning against a palm tree in a shaded area. She is looking out over a beautiful, calm beach in Aruba during the sunset with a golden horizon and pale blue skies above.

Aruba Cost of Stay 

Aruba is known as a high-end vacation spot, popular with newlyweds and families looking to indulge in an all-inclusive resort for a week.

You can enjoy dining at touristy restaurants and also find great local spots for a fraction of the price.

Most popular attractions in Aruba are free.

You don’t need a car in Aruba unless you want one, so you can save money by taking public transportation.

A woman wearing a sundress sitting on some rocks wedged in between palm trees, looking at the turquoise, calm beach. This area is located in Bottom Beach in Barbados. It's a partially overcast day with some clouds covering the sky towards the right side of the photo.

Barbados Cost of Stay 

While Aruba is known for its more expensive options, Barbados offers a more budget-friendly alternative. 

The island has an excellent public transportation system, making rental cars or pricey taxi rides unnecessary unless you want to explore remote areas. 

Basic food and accommodation options in Barbados are surprisingly affordable compared to other nearby islands. 

Best Things to Do

Barbados and Aruba both have so many things to do, you won’t get bored!

Woman standing on top of Casibari Rock Formation in Aruba, in awe of the views which include tons of trees, houses, and hills at a distance. It's also a sunny day with a bit of clouds splattered across the sky.

Aruba Things to Do

Aside from Oranjestad and San Nicholas, there aren’t many charming towns on the island of Aruba. But, there are plenty of exciting outdoor activities and off-the-beaten-path adventures to enjoy!

Seeing the island from a different perspective is a must-do, and a boat tour is the perfect way to do it! 

If you have some extra time, be sure to visit private islands such as Renaissance Island and De Palm Island where you can spot flamingos. 

History lovers will love to explore Bushiribana Ruins, a 19th-century gold mill and visit the iconic California Lighthouse. 

You can pack the best things to do into one day or choose to stay for up to a week in Aruba to experience everything!

Woman wearing a blue tank top, denim shorts, and black sandals looking at the boats on the water. She is in Bridgetown Boardwalk in Barbados. She is standing on a wooden pathway, with a bench, metal green fence, cars, and colourful buildings to her right.

Barbados Things to Do

It’s hard to choose where to start when there are so many fun activities to do in Barbados.

Learn about the rich culture of Barbados by visiting historical landmarks like the St. Nicholas Abbey or Bridgetown and its Garrison, recognized as a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

For breathtaking views, head to Deebles Point where you can admire a lighthouse, take in the scenery from a viewing platform, and browse an art gallery.

Experience the history of Barbados at Codrington College, a former sugar cane plantation turned Anglican theological college located in Saint John. This location is perfect for capturing memorable photos!

Whether you prefer relaxing on picturesque beaches or exploring the island’s past, there are plenty of options such as Harrison’s Cave and the Barbados Museum.

Take part in thrilling water activities, tour a rum distillery, or get some delicious mocktails at a lively beachfront bar.

With so much to do, you can plan your stay in Barbados for just one day or extend it to 5 days or more without running out of exciting activities.

Adventure Activities

It’s hard to side with Barbados or Aruba on this as both have amazing adventure activities!

A woman in a cold shoulder flowy grey shirt and denim shorts on a hiking tour of Arikok National Park in Aruba walking along a dirt path through cacti and other plants on an overcast day

Aruba Adventure Activities

If you want good views, go to Arikok National Park or go see unique rock formations like the Ayo Rock Formation and Natural Bridge.

Travellers looking for adventure can try windsurfing or kitesurfing at the well-known Fishermen’s Huts in Aruba. 

Another exciting way to experience Aruba’s rough terrain is by taking an ATV tour through the desert landscape, or for more of a challenge, opt for a hike. 

Aruba offers diving and tours that include snorkelling, although I enjoyed the snorkelling in Barbados better. 

Woman snorkeling underwater in Barbados with a turtle on her right, a shipwreck, and fish.

Barbados Adventure Activities

Barbados is a dream destination for those who want to snorkel alongside turtles. They often make their nests here, so it’s not uncommon to find them swimming nearby. My favourite spot to see turtles is Carlisle Bay. 

You can also visit Animal Flower Cave, situated at the northern tip of Barbados. It’s a natural limestone cave with unique tidal pools which visitors can take a dip in. I had the cave almost all to myself!

For a unique experience, take a ride on an electric tram through the underground limestone caverns at Harrison’s Cave. 

To see breathtaking views of the coastline, you can hike from Bath to Bathsheba Railway.

For surf lessons, head over to Brandon’s Beach. 

Everywhere you turn in Barbados, there is endless natural beauty waiting to be explored, making it the winner for me vs Aruba.

Landscapes & Beaches

Aruba and Barbados are far from similar when it comes to landscape. These two islands stand kilometres apart, with vastly different terrains.

A woman sitting under a Fofoti tree watching the sunset on eagle beach in Aruba. The water is calm, with light reflecting on the sun on the left side of the photo.

Aruba Landscapes & Beaches

Among all the Caribbean islands, Aruba is known for its stunning beaches. 

The most popular is Eagle Beach, with its soft white sands and crystal blue waters and its iconic Fofoti tree that stands tall on the sand. 

Other must-visit beaches in Aruba include Palm Beach, Natural Pool, and Baby Beach, which is my favourite.

Unlike Barbados, Aruba is dry and sandy, almost like a desert. You can see this in Arikok Park which covers almost 1/5th of the island. 

The Ayo and Casibari Rock Formations have a one-of-a-kind view of an otherwise flat landscape. I could see so far from the top of the rocks!

a woman walking along a white sand beach along the turquoise waters of Carlisle Bay Barbados. She is holding a bathing suit cover-up behind her. There are restaurants and boats in the far far distance. It's a beautiful day with some clouds covering the sky. When comparing Barbados vs Aruba beaches, Barbados was the winner for her

Barbados Landscapes & Beaches

Barbados has a variety of beaches to explore, from the soft sands of Crane Beach to the cliffs of Bathsheba. 

The best coral reefs are along the west coast of the island where all the best beaches are.

Carlisle Bay is my favourite beach for snorkelling with turtles and shipwrecks.

Accra Beach has boardwalks perfect for a scenic walk.

You can also visit vibrant botanical gardens and caves, both offering endless opportunities for discovery and adventure. And if you can’t decide where to start, an island tour is a great way to see more of Barbados’ diverse landscapes.

Compared to Aruba, Barbados is much more tropical, lush, and green. 

Weather

Both Barbados and Aruba have amazing weather year-round, although with some key differences.

Woman wearing a turquoise top, leaning on the Red Anchor, a historic landmark in Aruba that overlooks some grassy areas and the beach on a sunny day. The Red Anchor is about 4.72 meters tall

Aruba Weather

Located outside of the hurricane belt, one of the highlights of Aruba is its consistently warm and sunny climate. 

The weather in Aruba is more enjoyable, with less rain compared to Barbados and other islands.

When planning a summer or fall getaway, Aruba is the best choice to have plenty of beach days without worrying about storms.

I chose to visit during Christmas and it wasn’t too busy and I had great weather. 

View of Speightstown Pier in Barbados during sunset. The water is calm and the sky has deep orange tones mixed with muted blue with clouds scattered all over.

Barbados Weather

Barbados is known for its consistently pleasant climate, thanks to the cooling trade winds and low humidity levels.

The rainy season from June to November brings short rain showers and occasional tropical storms, these are usually followed by sunny weather. 

I got lucky with no rain during a visit to Barbados in September.

During the dry season from December to May, visitors can enjoy clear skies and perfect beach weather, making it an ideal time for outdoor activities and cultural exploration.

Food 

The cuisine of Aruba and Barbados reflects a diverse range of influences, resulting in a variety of must-try dishes that showcase their exceptional seafood offerings.

A woman wearing a white peplum top holding two drinks, standing in front of The Pastechi House, a restaurant in Aruba dedicated to pastechi, an Aruban meat-filled pastry. There are some waiters walking around and people eating inside the restaurant.

Aruba Food

The culinary scene in Aruba is a fusion of Dutch, South American, and Caribbean flavours. 

Keshi Yena, a large ball of cheese stuffed with chicken, is the national dish of Aruba.

A must-try snack is Pastechis, a fried pastry filled with meat and vegetables that I found delicious. 

And for those craving familiar tastes, Aruba has a vast selection of restaurants serving international cuisines and popular chain eateries.

No matter what type of food you’re in the mood for, you won’t have trouble finding it on this island.

A fish sandwich with lettuce, wrapped in tissue from Cuz's Fish Stand in Barbados

Barbados Food

Barbados also offers a variety of food influenced by a blend of African, Indian, Irish, Caribbean, and English cultures. 

Fresh seafood options abound, including flying fish and grilled mahi-mahi seasoned with local spices and herbs. 

For a delicious fish sandwich, stop by Cuz Fish Stand which is right on the beach. I loved it so much that I even visited twice during my trip! 

Be sure not to miss out on trying Bajan specialties like macaroni pie and pudding and souse, or indulge in some street food at Oistins Fish Fry where you can find grilled fish, lobster, and more. And if you have the time, I highly recommend going on a Barbados food tour.

Even the food on my boat tour was delicious! You really can’t go wrong eating anywhere.

For the food battle of Barbados vs Aruba, Barbados was the winner for me.

Culture & Vibe

Despite both islands being in the Caribbean, Aruba and Barbados are distinct islands separated by over 1000 km and boasting unique cultures.

The Royal Plaza, a pink coloured shopping mall in Oranjestad, Aruba with white and turquoise accents. There are some a few people walking down the mall with some cars, and the streets are shaded while the sun is out. When comparing Aruba vs Barbados culture, Aruba was more Americanized.

Aruba Culture & Vibe

Although Aruba is a popular tourist spot, it may feel less authentic compared to other islands including Antigua and Barbados. 

As a Dutch overseas territory, it has become highly Americanized and commercialized. However, this does not mean it lacks charm or value as a travel destination. 

With its multitude of large resorts, chain restaurants, vibrant nightlife, and abundant shopping options, Aruba draws in vacationers and newlyweds. 

There is never a dull moment here with plenty of activities to enjoy!

Woman wearing a bathing suit and coverup while walking on the edge of the calm, turquoise beach in Carlisle Bay in Barbados. Beyond the distance, there are boats, restaurants, and trees on a partially cloudy day.

Barbados Culture & Vibe

Barbados is a lively island, full of culture and life. 

There’s never a dull moment here, from the lively rhythms of calypso and reggae music to the vibrant celebrations of the Crop Over Festival. 

Even though it can get crowded at times, I liked the relaxed vibes of Barbados more.

Learn about the island’s rich history by visiting landmarks like George Washington House and the Barbados Museum, or soak up the local lifestyle in bustling markets and neighbourhoods.

Affordable Accommodations

Both islands have a variety of affordable luxury accommodations to choose from.

Rooftop pool in Aruba at night with the lights on inside the pool, showcasing a teal color. There are three steps to the bottom of the pool. To the left of the pool, there are three umbrellas over a row of beach chairs, and there is some blue lighting over the umbrellas. The rooftop pool area overlooks street lights, palm trees, and Aruba's cityscape.

Aruba Affordable Accommodations

While Barbados may have more affordable lodging options, Aruba offers a wider range of accommodations at a slightly higher cost.

Most resorts are located around Palm Beach and Eagle Beach. These accommodations vary from lavish 5-star resorts to more economical choices. 

As you venture further away from the beaches, you can find even more budget-friendly options. 

I stayed in Oranjestad for its convenient access to public transportation and proximity to the airport. 

For a more affordable stay at the high-rise resorts along the beaches, visit in the off-season.

People swimming on Pebbles Beach in Barbados on a sunny day with some clouds covering the sky. There are some boats, trees, and hotels at a far distance.
My hotel in Barbados was right on the beach

Barbados Affordable Accommodations

Barbados has surprisingly affordable luxury accommodations.

These options include charming guesthouses near popular attractions.

You can also find budget-friendly hotels directly on the beach, like I did.

Areas like St. Lawrence Gap, Worthing, and Hastings offer various options for comfortable stays, all within walking distance to beaches, dining spots, and exciting nightlife.

Transportation

This factor can make or break your vacation. Both islands have great public transport but in the battle of Aruba vs Barbados, Aruba steals this one. 

A blue and yellow bus called Arubus, which is the main mode of public transportation in Aurba. It's under the San Nicolas bus station on a sunny day.

Aruba Transportation

For those who prefer using public transportation, Aruba is a more reliable option than Barbados. 

Daily bus lines run from 5:45 am to 11:30 pm, making it easy and affordable to travel to popular tourist areas. You can even take the bus near Arikok (although not inside!) 

But, if you want more flexibility in your travels, renting a car is also an option. The main roads in Aruba are well-maintained, but driving in remote areas may be more challenging.

I only needed a rental car for one day to explore the National Park, as most places can be reached by bus. 

back of people's heads from the view of sitting at the back of a crowded bus in Barbados

Barbados Transportation

Barbados also has an efficient public transportation system, that’s slightly worse than Aruba but better coverage than in Antigua. 

It’s easy to get around with the various bus routes covering the entire island but you do have to walk through Bridgetown to catch the bus north.

Make sure to double-check your route as it’s easy to get on the wrong bus! I ended up at Harrison’s Cave instead of Animal Flower Cave.

While car rentals are still an option, it’s nice not having to rely on one every day.

Barbados vs Aruba FAQs

Is Aruba Nicer than Barbados?

No, Aruba is not nicer than Barbados. But it is ultimately up to your preferences. Aruba is more known for its desert-like climate and stunning beaches while Barbados boasts a more tropical scenery and vibrant nightlife. 

Is Aruba Close to Barbados?

No, Aruba is not close to Barbados. They are 1,132 km from each other. The closest islands to Barbados are Saint Lucia and St.Vincent & the Grenadines.

Is Aruba Windy Like Barbados?

Yes, Aruba is windy like Barbados. But Aruba has stronger trade winds than Barbados.

So, Is Aruba or Barbados Better for Your Next Vacation?

Whether Aruba or Barbados is better will depend on your personal preference.

Aruba is better for reliable public transit, a wider variety of hotel and food options, and consistent weather year-round.

Barbados is ideal for cheaper seafood, better beaches, affordable accommodations on the beach, and people wanting to swim with turtles.

For me, the winner was Barbados because of the delicious seafood and snorkelling over shipwrecks. But I truly loved my time in both!

Whatever you choose, you’ll have an incredible Caribbean experience.

Travelling to the Caribbean? Read More:

Melissa is the founder of My Beautiful Passport. A Canadian who has explored 20+ countries on 4 continents, she enjoys combining soft adventure and affordable luxury. Through sharing her own experiences, travel tips, and destination itineraries, she helps others plan their unique adventures whether it be at the beach, in the city, or in the mountains.