Where to Stay in NYC at Christmas (3 Best Areas & Hotels)

Deciding where to stay in NYC at Christmas is an important step in planning your trip, as the city is quite spread out.

Do you want to be near the best holiday attractions? Near food? Or save money and stay outside of Manhattan?

I visited all the best areas in New York City and stayed in 2 different locations to compare.

While staying in Queens was more affordable, I spent a lot of time transporting into Manhattan every day. I loved staying in Midtown.

Let’s get right into the best places to stay in NYC for Christmas, including things to do nearby.

This post may contain affiliate links. We may receive a small commission (at no extra cost to you) on qualifying purchases so we can continue to create helpful content. Thank you, and we appreciate it. See our disclosure policy for more information.

Table of Contents

Where to Stay in NYC at Christmas: Overview

Best for first-timers: Midtown Manhattan

Best for sightseeing and culture: Downtown Manhattan

Best for affordability: Brooklyn

Midtown Manhattan: Best For First-Time Visitors

Midtown Manhattan is overall the best neighbourhood in New York to stay in during Christmas.

I stayed here on one of my Christmas NYC trips, and I love how it is near most of the festive activities, and a great base to get around the rest of New York City. So much faster to get anywhere from here than commuting in from other parts of the city.

The majority of famous holiday lights and displays are in the area, so you can easily spend 3 days in New York around here.

Things to Do in Midtown Manhattan at Christmas

See the Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree, the most iconic Christmas tree in the city
Go ice skating in front of the Rockefeller Center
Take photos with the Christmas decorations at Radio City Music Hall
See the Radio City Rockettes Christmas Spectacular at Radio City – this alone was worth visiting New York City at Christmas for
Admire the NYC skyline from Top of the Rock – it’s even better than the Empire State Building viewpoint since you can see it
Stroll through Central Park and even go ice skating on the large ice rink
Admire the iconic holiday display at Macy’s, and enjoy window shopping at other beautifully decorated stores along 5th Avenue, including the Saks 5th Avenue Light Show
Visit Columbus Circle Christmas Market for the European Christmas Market atmosphere in NYC
Wander Bryant Park Winter Village, a charming holiday market with an ice rink and festive food stalls
Get the tickets to see The Nutcracker at the New York City Ballet

Our Top Choice: Hyatt Centric Times Square New York

It doesn’t get better than staying in Times Square for your first visit to New York City.

The city’s most iconic square is lively all the time, and you’ll quickly see why New York is called the city that never sleeps.

Hyatt Centric Times Square offers the best of both worlds, a fantastic central location, but in a quieter street than staying directly on the Square.

Rooms are spacious and luxurious, creating a cozy retreat to return to and warm up after a day of exploring.

Most Unique: Dream Midtown

Dream Midtown is one of the best Christmas hotels in NYC, best known for its spectacular Christmas decorations and a rooftop terrace with a view of the city skyline.

The hotel is ideally located within walking distance of most Christmas attractions in the city, including Columbus Circle Holiday Market at Central Park, Rockefeller Center, and Broadway.

Rooms in Dream Midtown are spacious, and you can choose between regular rooms with double beds and suites with a separate seating area with city views.

Affordable Luxury Hotel: EVEN Hotel Times Square

Midtown Manhattan is one of the more expensive areas to stay in New York, but that doesn’t mean you can’t find affordable options!

EVEN Hotel is located slightly outside the main tourist area, but close to everything at the same time. You’re also just a short walk from the subway station, making it easy to get around by public transportation.

Rooms are nicely decorated and make for a cozy home base after a day in the City.

Downtown Manhattan: Best For Sightseeing and Culture

Downtown Manhattan is a great place to stay for more affordable accommodation options, sightseeing opportunities, and easy access to the main tourist attractions.

Christmas time is one of the best times to visit NYC, so the downtown area is busy during the day, but surprisingly calm at night and on the weekends.

A downside of staying far in the south is that you’ll have to go to Midtown to discover NYC nightlife.

Things to Do in Downtown Manhattan at Christmas

Check out the giant Christmas tree at 11 Wall Street and the festive lights at the New York Stock Exchange
Visit One World Trade Center and the 9/11 Memorial, it’s not very festive but an important part of the city’s history and great for a rainy winter day
Take a ferry to the Statue of Liberty and Staten Island, one of the most popular things to do in New York
Go on a festive brunch or holiday jazz river cruise

Our Top Choice: AC Hotel New York Downtown

AC Hotel is one of the best hotels in New York for Christmas if you prefer to escape the crowds in Midtown Manhattan and enjoy a calmer place to stay.

The hotel offers that iconic Downtown atmosphere, allowing you to admire the surrounding glass skyscrapers or enjoy stunning views of the East River from your room.

Rooms feature large comfortable beds and floor-to-ceiling windows that let in plenty of winter sun.

Most Unique: Washington Square Hotel

If you’re unsure where to stay in NYC for Christmas, the Washington Square Hotel perfectly balances proximity to the main tourist area with the charm of a historic property in a calm neighbourhood.

The hotel is situated on the edge of Downtown Manhattan, close to the trendy Greenwich Village.

Dating back to the early 20th century, this hotel also gets beautifully decorated for Christmas which only emphasizes its unique charm.

Affordable Luxury Hotel: Arlo Soho

Arlo SoHo is one of the best value-for-money hotels in the city, and a great place to stay at Christmas time.

Situated in the trendy SoHo neighbourhood, this hotel features a modern, clean style with elegant and interesting design choices that make for an upscale retreat.

Brooklyn: Best For Affordability

Brooklyn is the best area to stay in New York for Christmas if you’re on a budget or it is your second visit to the city and you want to get off the beaten track.

Downtown Brooklyn and Williamsburg are fantastic neighbourhoods to stay when you want to enjoy a lively neighbourhood and explore local culture away from the usual tourist hotspots.

Things to Do in Brooklyn at Christmas

Admire all the Christmas Lights in Dyker Heights, where residents go all out with decorating their houses
Walk the iconic Brooklyn Bridge, and take photos from the popular DUMBO photo location
Ice skate underneath the Brooklyn Bridge with NYC skyline views at Glide ice rink
See Brooklyn Botanic Garden Lightscape, a wining trail running through the Botanic Garden illuminated with Christmas lights
Enjoy the Nutcracker ballet in King’s Theater for a fraction of the price of the New York City Ballet

Our Top Choice: EVEN Hotel Brooklyn

EVEN Hotel Brooklyn is the best place to stay in New York if you’re looking for a budget-friendly and comfortable hotel away from the main tourist area.

The hotel is situated just a 2-minute walk from the metro that takes you right to the heart of Manhattan, Central Park, and Times Square.

Rooms are bright and quite spacious for New York standard, the perk of being outside the city center.

Most Unique: Wyndham Garden Brooklyn Sunset Park

Situated just a short metro ride from the festive Dyker Heights neighbourhood, Wyndham Garden Brooklyn Sunset Park is one of the best NYC Christmas hotels.

This eco-friendly hotel has spacious rooms with one or two double beds, which makes it perfect for those travelling with friends, family, and couples.

Affordable Luxury Hotel: NU Hotel Brooklyn

If you’re seeking a place you’ll look forward to coming back to every night, NU Hotel Brooklyn is the one for you.

This affordable luxury hotel is situated in the heart of Brooklyn, just a short metro ride from the trendy DUMBO neighbourhood and Glide ice skating rink.

Rooms are bright and spacious, with complimentary L’Occitane toiletries for a pampering experience. You also have access to the gym, or you can borrow one of the hotel bikes on warmer winter days.

Final Thoughts on Where To Stay In New York At Christmas

Midtown Manhattan is the best place to stay in NYC for Christmas, as it is close to most Christmas activities and tourist attractions.

Downtown Manhattan and Brooklyn are great alternatives if you’re travelling on a budget this holiday season, and depending on how many days in NYC you have.

I stayed in Midtown Manhattan and loved being within walking distance of all the attractions.

Now that you know where is the best place to stay in New York during Christmas, it’s time to start planning your New York Christmas itinerary to ensure you visit all the iconic landmarks!